Originally Posted by r'aggro
It's not. Smith gets a lot of love for his unmatched toughness and leadership abilities, but he really isn't a good d-man anymore. He's too slow (slower than Hatcher) and has a lot of trouble clearing the puck for some reason. The fact that he's such a tough SOB is the reason he got signed; the guy was actually playing the Pittsburgh series with not one but TWO separated shoulders...and no one knew about until after it was over, because he never complained or made any excuses. I take my hat off to Gator, but Philly was right not to offer him...especially at the 2.75 per year that the Sens paid him.