Printable View
Our wireless router died and I'm looking for a replacement unit. I think the new one should be "N" compatible. For the rest reliability and performance is the primary concern. I'm looking to spend around 50-60 euros. So far I have something in mind like the Linksys WRT160N and the Netgear WNR2000. What do you think? Is there anything else out there that is better for this price? Thank you.
I'd get the LINKSYS WRT160NL with the extrenal antennas.
I like the D-Link DIR-825 and DIR-855. Linksys has gone downhill and Netgear was never good.
The D-Link routers you mentioned here are out of my price range. The Linksys seems good although I don't really like the design but that's secondary.
What about the Belkin N+ router or the Netgear WNR3500 RangeMax? There is a D-Link that's closer to what I want to spend, it's the DIR-635 or even the DIR-655, any good? There is just so many choice, I did a search on this forum for routers but most of the posts are referring to "G" models. Eventually I'll just have to pick one and get going.
After reading numerous review's I just ordered a D-Link 655 ... Most of the review's were positive. I ordered a refurbished from Best Buy for $79.00 +s&h
I noticed the DLink routers came out in 2007. I don't really know if that matters but for comparison the Linksys WRT160NL and the WRT320N are both from mid 2009. Are the external antennas important features about those routers because I see some only have them internally? Right now I'm debating whether I go for either of the Linksys I just referred here or the DIR-635 from D-Link. Any experience with those here?
Been there done that with the Dlink, Netgear, Linksys stuff. For me, Linksys wins. And I like the external antenna(s), better, solid connections.
There are only two products I can recommend for entry level: The Cisco WRVS4400N, and the Apple AirPorts. Everything else I've ever tried has to be "reset" constantly, and IMO that's unacceptable. A router should NEVER have to be reset unless you are pushing a firmware update.
You can save money and buy a $50 router, but have fun getting pissed off at having to reset it at least once a week.
If you buy a good router it will last forever and never have to be reset. And if you ever want a new one, you can sell the old one. Buy a $200 Cisco route today, and you'll never have a problem with it and be able to sell it for $120 in 3-years. Buy a $50 crap-box and you'll end up having to buy two of them in three years and they'll both end up being worthless.
If $200 is too much to spend on a router, consider getting an Apple AirPort express for $99. I know, you'll have an evil Apple product in your house. It's okay, you can hide it away and you don't have to tell anyone.
I use a Dlink 655. Its awesome, never had a problem with it and always gives me strong signals throughout my house.
I come from a Linksys WRT54G and it worked well for me for a couple of years. I looked at the Apple Express and it seems pretty small in size for a router. I'm going to look for some reviews on that little piece of hardware. Glancing at the picture, it seems though I wouldn't be able to add a switch to the router. For that purpose I would need the Apple Extreme Base Station.
OS Wiz: What would you choose between the WRT320N and the WRT160NL?Quote:
Been there done that with the Dlink, Netgear, Linksys stuff. For me, Linksys wins. And I like the external antenna(s), better, solid connections.
They are the same price where I live.
Thanks for all the help.
I've had my $49.00 Linksys WRT54GL for 3 yrs and have NEVER had to reset it ... Maybe just luckly but I have not heard of the amount of problems you suggest with the cheap $50 units. I run 4 desktops and 2 laptops from it .. Just my 2 cents worth ....Quote:
Originally Posted by ImaNihilist
WRT54GL and flash it with Tomato Firmware.
It's my standard answer but with my router lasting for months at a time without a reboot... It's a pretty good answer. Hell you don't even need to tweak anything if you're not up to it.
It's not 802.11n-capable. Whatsoever. But it's the Toyota Pickups of consumer routers - the damn things just won't die.
I have a Buffalo WHR-HP-G54 router that has never been rebooted since its initial installation (IIRC) about 5 years ago.
My next AP (802.11n) will most likely be a Cisco Airport.
The WRT160NL.Quote:
Originally Posted by Coolme
OK thanks.Quote:
Originally Posted by OS-Wiz
I'm going to end up with either the DIR-825 or the WRT160NL.
Just have to read some more reviews.
I ended up with the D-Link based on reviews.
Thanks for all the input!
Coolme
Prolly out of the price range, but I like the Netgear SRXN3250. Best thing I've seen this side of Cisco.
Personally I run a SonicWALL TZ200 with the Comprehensive Gateway Security Suite. Totally pimp for a home. Content filtering, Antivirus/Antispyware/IPS right on your gateway. SSL VPN. Kickass. I honestly don't think you can get anything better than that for the money. Blows anything Cisco out of the water in it's price range. ASAs are crap compared to it. A full 35mbps of true UTM throughput. Nice.
I hang a cheap Linksys N Router off of it just as an AP in it's own portshield group. Nothing ever needs to be reset.