I like or have liked all of those games you mention, so I have to disagree. I don't think any of them are overrated.

I guess it depends upon when you played the games, and what you consider "overrated".

I went back and played Goldeneye yesterday, and I thought "Wow this game pretty much sucks compared to todays FPS!" So I guess I could say "Goldeneye" is overrated.

Perspective is everything, I think all of those games were damn good games at the time they came out.