JDC or Nabby, I need an SJ fan's opinion on Matt Carle.

tsn.ca

As I stated above Philly is looking to add a promising d-man, but just gave up a real fan favorite in Steve Downie to get one. And, Eminger is not bad in the first place (and cheaper than Carle), so I think this trade stinks as of right now.

Are congrats or condolences in order?