Mass Effect first play through

[taggart6]

it gives more freedom in the game. if you have one maxed and the other not, that other paragon/renegade option will be grayed out. i like the idea of making any choice at my whim. usually those options will enable you to avoid or engage in fights and help bargain prices, or get people to give you items. the regular options usually don't get you squat except a lowered amount of paragon or renegade points. also, for maximum effect, you should always take a top or bottom choice. 9 out of 10 times, the middle one will net you no gain in anything.

I maxed out both choices but in a recent conversation both were grayed out. I thought that was strange.

I think I will re start my game. Go renegade solider and just focus on intimidation.